Saturday, March 24, 2012

Poor Trayvon. Please sign the petition at www.change.org/trayvon?

These are the words that keep going through my head this past week. I appreciate the "?" at the end of the petition link. It is a question. Why did this young boy have to die?
Although it is a legal vs political issue, how can I not post about something that has truly affected me along with this entire nation.
For those of you that have been living under a rock :-), Trayvon Martin is a 17year old black teen that was shot to death by a neighborhood watch captain in a gated community in central Florida. He was a cute teen, small in build that had never been in any trouble. His only crimes were being black, wearing a hoodie and walking through his own neighborhood on his way back from the convenience store. He was carrying ice tea and a box of skittles. Mr.Zimmerman, the neighborhood watch captain, saw him walking through the neighborhood and called 911. Even though Trayvon was not committing a crime. He then followed him against the advice of the 911 operator, got out of his car with a gun and approached Trayvon. He claimed an altercation occurred and he shot him in self defense. He was taller and about 100 pounds heavier than Trayvon. He has not been arrested which has led to a public outcry including school walkouts, marches, vigils and even the President and players in the NBA making a stance and posting pictures of themselves in hoodies (sweatshirts with hoods).
This case has brought up several issues that I would like to discuss. 1)Racial profiling 2)Hate crimes 3) "Stand Your Ground" laws.
1) Racial profiling. The police are often accused of doing this. Everyone has heard the stories of black men in expensive cars being pulled over. Why? Because they are black men in expensive cars. Minorities of both races in rich all white communities are also often targets. Why? Because it is felt that they don't belong. How many black people have been followed around by security guards-sometimes also black-in expensive stores such as Gucci or Louis Vuitton? Why? Because the thought process is-since they probably cant afford such items, they will steal them. But this behavior is not unique to security guards or police officers. We all have prejudices based on race, age,sex and culture. Anyone who says otherwise is lying. I know it is true even of myself. If I am in my car alone at 2am, stopped at a red light and a bright turquoise "hooptie" car on high wheels, with thick rims, blasting loud music pulls up next to me, I would not think twice about running the red light out of fear of being car jacked or followed. Yes, I said it because it is true. I think the best example of racial profiling and prejudice is the Oscar winning film- CRASH. Everyone should watch that movie. Everyone should own up to their own prejudices and deal with them. Everyone should be aware of how they may affect how you treat others. Be aware that such treatment could unknowingly turn out deadly.
2) Hate crimes. Over the years I have been torn about this issue. Harsher and longer penalties given to those who commit crimes due to hatred of a particular race or creed. For instance, killing someone because he or she is gay and you hate gay people vs killing someone just because it was part of a robbery, rape, or you just felt like it. To me, somehow getting more jail time for one murder over the other felt as if one life was worth more than the other. I personally feel any murder or horrific crime warrants life in prison or the death penalty no matter what the motive is. However, recent cases have made me realize that we must take a stance that this nation will not stand for crimes against anyone solely out of hate. To make the penalties harsher or longer may deter those that target a particular group of people. In Mississippi, 3 men recently plead guilty to federal hate crimes after running over and beating a black man to death. A black man that they randomly found and attacked in a hotel parking lot because they hate N***. A Rutgers University student was recently found guilty of a hate crime for spying on his gay roommate via a web cam and discussing it on twitter. He denies doing so out of hate or that he is homophobic. His roommate committed suicide a few days later. And now the Trayvon Martin case. The man who admits to shooting and killing him is half Hispanic and denies being racist. How then can he explain his suspicions of this young teen, his decision to call 911, hunt him down and kill him without provocation? So yes, I now believe in the federal hate crime legislation that was passed in 2009. We must make it clear that in America these obscene behaviors and crimes will not be tolerated.
3) The "Stand Your Ground" law. Florida was the first to pass this law in 2005 (why am I not surprised). Since then 16 more states have passed similar laws. It allows someone to use deadly force if they "reasonably believe" they must defend themselves from a threat. Since 2005, there has been an increase in shootings of unarmed individuals were self defense was claimed and therefore the shooter was not arrested or prosecuted. Proponents of the law state that it was intended for people to protect themselves from home invasion or real physical danger such as rape or a serious physical attack. None of the above is the case with this watch captain who was warm and safe in his car with his gun who chose to follow Trayvon and get out of his car with such gun to approach and antagonize the smaller unarmed teen. Even supporters of the law have spoken out against Mr.Zimmerman's actions and state shooting in self defense must require a real fear that your life is in danger.Those who oppose the law basically call it a license to kill and based on the statistics, I somewhat agree. In the end, if this neighborhood watch captain is able to get away with murder based on this law, it surely needs to be revisited and reworded or revoked!
Thoughts?

4 comments:

  1. @3) http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/14/nyregion/komisarjevsky-convicted-of-triple-murder-in-cheshire-conn.html

    The victims probably wished they owned a weapon to "Stand Your Ground". I never thought I would need a gun for protection. But what if the occasion calls for me to protect my family. Do I need a law to say what I can or cannot do? I am not insane or trigger happy, but you bet I will shoot to kill, as a last resort, if you are in my house or on my property uninvited and a threat.

    Personally, I feel that there is more to the story about Zimmerman, sorry cannot give a respectful title, like Mr. There is something about him that we just don't know, yet, like his mental stability.

    I signed the petition.

    I saw this phrase today "Respect starts with understanding". It wasn't in any context and means a lot. Maybe Zimmerman needed/needs more understanding? Maybe we all need to re-learn some respect.

    "Do unto others as you would have others do unto you. [Matthew 7:12]"

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree in the case about home invasion or if your life is truly threatened. It also reminds me of the case where that young woman was in her home with her baby, her husband had just died serving in the military and two men were trying to break into her home. She was on the phone with the 911 operator and shot the first intruder and then the second one ran off. Yes sad that a man died but I agreed with that woman and thought she was so brave.
    Apparently Zimmerman is a vigilante wannabe cop and there had been recent break ins in the neighborhood. If only he had just let the cops arrived and handle whatever situation he thought was going to occur. Sad waste of a good life. A mother and father losing their son over nothing.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I thought it was interesting that you mentioned the film, "Crash". It was a really thought-provoking movie that dealt with pre-conceived notions and profiling. In an ironic twist, it won the Oscar, over "Brokeback Moutain", a film with 2 gay characters. Everyone expected it to win, but Hollywood was not ready for that.

    As for Trayvon, I feel sick. I have a son and I wept for him as the details of the case unfolded. I wondered how old he would be before he got stopped, when someone called him the N word, or when a woman would clutch her purse and fear rape, simply because of his (beautiful) brown skin. Sadly, the first time I pondered these things, he was just a few days old.

    As for the sinister hoodie, Geraldo, please give me a list of things that black people can't wear. Perhaps my lab coat that says "Dr" is offensive to those who believe I work for dietary. Maybe the ominous suit my brother was wearing at age 13 when he walked home from a Bar Mitzvah in Beverly Hills caused the police to stop him. The only hoodie I fear is the white pointed one.

    My take on George Zimmerman: a wanna-be rentacop vigilante looking for trouble. What made him think Trayvon was on drugs? Why was he carrying a gun as a neighborhood volunteer? Despite all of this uproar, I know he will get away with it. I have little faith in the system. But maybe something good will come out of this. Better race relations? I think not. Trayon's Law? A law that staes you can not pursue someone without cause, then claim self-defense; or even anti-racial profiling law...Please don't let his death be in vain.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I still dont think Hollywood or most people are ready for Brokeback mountain!! I thought it was a beautiful movie but certain scenes were difficult to watch. I imagined a lot of my friends with black boys and how this must really hit home. I have not heard anyone ask Zimmerman's attorney or friends what made him call 911 or what made him tell them he was acting like he was on drugs. And if not racist or prejudiced, what did he mean by "they always get away". And noone has explained why he felt the need to get out of his car with his own gun. Noone has said anything as to what Trayvon was doing that made Zimmerman so suspicious and what was his urgency to approach this kid with a gun. This didnt have to happen. I hope it is a wake up call and his death isnt in vain.

    ReplyDelete